Break ins were becoming more common in our area that it prompted my mother to buy another dog. What she came home with was a scraggly, flea-ridden Doberman-German shepherd mutt we eventually named “Whispy.” My mom didn’t consider her for her shameful state, but rather, she was sold almost for nothing because the vendor just wanted to get rid of her and was worried if the poor dog would sell at all.
After an extensive defleaing and cleaning, Whispy showed signs of being an observant and capable guard dog. Despite her small and fragile stature, she was a terror when she barred her fangs at strangers and reserved her loyalty and adoration only to us. She would change her behavior when she realized that a stranger was part of family or a friend based on what she would observe from our behavior. She was great at keeping traveling Jehovah’s witnesses away who were too scared to preach the word of God in the face of this “menacing” wolf.
Since I was rarely allowed to go out even to play with the next door neighbor’s girl, I ended up playing with the dogs instead. Whispy was my favorite even though it was difficult to play tricks on her. She ended up being my confidant and the shoulder to cry on. She became my “first” best friend. She was so fond of me that my mother always had to call me in order for her to obey commands.
One summer evening, I woke up to faint sounds of squealing and Whispy’s distinct whine of worry. I realized that she has started giving birth to puppies before I opened the door outside and alerted my brothers immediately. As soon as we came out, she looked relieved and had two puppies crawling all over the place. She couldn’t help herself and didn’t know if she should look after the two puppies crawling away or deliver the rest of the puppies still in progress. She looked like she was having difficulty delivering the huge pups because of her small frame so my younger brother was assigned the task of keeping the puppies close to her so she didn’t worry about them, and I helped by playing midwife to the puppies being delivered. My older brother held the two other dogs we owned since they caused Whispy to growl protectively over the puppies. In the end, we ended up with five dogs. One was unfortunately still born and looked like a mutant with a giant head. Whispy had a longing look in her face when we took the dead puppy from her but didn’t retaliate. We dug a small grave for the puppy that same day and offered a little prayer for it. We set out milk to a haggard Whispy who looked grateful and set on to nurse the remaining pups.
After some years, Whispy became pregnant again. We were just as excited and spoiled her. One morning I stepped out and called to her as usual but didn’t get a bark or her presence. Furthermore, none of the dogs were responding to the call either. One of her pups actually came to see me, then darted away. When I turned the corner, I saw that they were all gathered at Whispy’s body. I didn’t want to believe it at first because it didn’t look like what I thought it was. She still looked alive except for a few flies flying around her. I came closer to confirm, my heart pounding in my chest. She was dead. I stroked her a few more times just to make sure, still not believing and I felt heartbroken when I hand moved over her swollen belly. She was due only a few more weeks.
I informed my mom right away, clearly keeping my hysteria at bay. I was expecting to be given one of those TV moment pats in the back or even some show of how sorry she was for my loss but I didn’t get any. I watched her order my older brother and an uncle to put her body in a sack and throw it at the creek next door. I kept thinking, “What? Aren’t we going to give her a funeral? She’s been with us for so long and you know how much I adore this dog!” I was told to get out of the way. Not knowing what to do with myself, I resorted to staying in my room, shocked, holding back tears, but crying eventually. It was a beautiful day for her to die. The weather was fine and the sun streamed into the only window that lit my dim room. Everyone in the household treated it like an ordinary day. The dogs were in a state of unrest and had to be kept to keep from distracting my brother and my uncle from moving the body. After some time, I did come out of my room and watched as her body was put into a sack and carried away.
It took me a very long time before I could finally pass the bridge alongside the creek where she was dumped. This was hard to do as it was only a house away from our home so I practically had to cross the street to go around it constantly. It took me three months to finally gain the courage to look down at the creek and look at the sack with her body in it. I didn’t have to look for it since it was still there. I only hoped that she wasn’t in pain and was very happy for the duration of her life with us. The whole ordeal made me wonder how people would feel should I die but this was definitely the beginning of a vague small voice telling me that there is no heaven or hell, only this earth and the life I’m living right now.
I’ve witnessed my mom break down during a previous birthday party I had when she received notification that her older brother in the navy had just passed away from a heart attack. She often spoke fondly of him and we felt much gratitude for his omniscience since he always seemed to be the mysterious figure behind an unexpected present or just the amount of money we needed to get through. For the rest of that celebration, I had mixed feelings of being happy for myself and being sad for my mom. I tried not to smile as my offer of condolence.
I was in 4th grade when Whispy died. Though I knew there was a huge difference between a human being and a pet dog, I was expecting some kind of speech about life and death from my mom. Anything would have comforted me but I was left to explore that myself. Even though my mom acknowledge us as “mature” kids, I still hoped she would be a bit more attentive to matters such as this. After an unexpected flood, I passed by the creek again to visit her and found that the sack was no longer there.
Several years later, my mother’s mom passed away. The funeral was comparable to a celebrity since I found several strangers, perhaps every occupant of the apartment building she lived in, and distant relatives in attendance. I was “ordered” to do the Eulogy for my grandmother and despite some difficulty with it, did manage to write a decent one. I had to show it to my father for review because just the thought of it made my mother breakdown in tears. In it, I essentially narrated my short correspondence with her when she still had the ability to write letters. She had lovely hand writing and I would talk to her about how the family was doing, my hobbies and stuff I wanted. Despite knowing that her favorite grandchild is my older brother, I was the only one diligent enough to write to her. I shared language misunderstandings we had with her in her later years when her memory started to fail and would order us something in Spanish and forget that we don’t speak that language at all. I think the crowd got the gist of it. They laughed and sighed at the appropriate parts despite my choked delivery as I found myself breaking down. When it was all over, I returned to where my family stood and got a half hug from my mother who thanked me and cried right back in my father’s arms. Throughout the rest of the mass, I grieved alone. I held my tears and felt envious that my mother had my father and my brothers stood close to each other, both heads bowed. My aunt and cousins were in front, I had other distant relatives behind who occasionally patted me in the back for the “wonderful” speech but despite all this, I felt very lonely being the only person within that crowd without a shoulder to cry on. When it was time for the viewing, I found that my grandmother’s body was that of a stranger. It resembled her, but it wasn’t anything like her.
My grandmother’s body reminded me of the death of our neighbor’s daughter in law who died young of cancer. There were perhaps at least 10 people in attendance in her funeral, not including us. We were invited as our neighbor thought of us as her grandchildren since she babysat us and we babysat her grandchildren. The lady who died looked calm and ethereal in her coffin. She didn’t get the chance to live a long, colorful life the way my grandmother did and unfortunately left a beautiful daughter behind.
I don’t know how to mourn. There are many times I’d like to cry hysterically the way they do it in movies but had been trained to avoid this since my mother had a habit of criticizing me for a drama queen when I did. I could never get the routine right despite many elderly relatives dropping dead every year or so. When silently crying to myself wasn’t acceptable either, the only other option available to me was to feel nothing, after all there is heaven, right?
I believe that religion’s first purpose is to answer death. It’s “comforting” to know that an afterlife exists where you can find your loved ones later on. I will never have a dog like Whispy ever again and as a child, it was comforting to “know” that she’ll be the first one to greet me when I die. I don’t think of it that way anymore, I don’t believe there’s anything after I’m gone so I’ve resorted to leaving crafty presents behind to my friends to ensure my immortality.
Will we see all our loved ones in some afterlife? I just couldn’t believe that, no, not after what I’ve seen. Not after the overwhelming response of the crowd that attended my grandmother’s funeral. It wouldn’t have been that big of a deal if they thought they wouldn’t see her again. Not after the unceremonious nature of Whispy’s funeral. Religious or not, there’s that part of us that knows that this is the only life we’ll ever live.

You must be a movie fan. “Do Dogs Dream of Heaven” sounds like
“Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?” I loved that movie also because
it forces its viewers to ponder just what it takes to make a human
a human.
I remember a question I read years ago in the “Ask Father Ryan”
column of the Catholic Digest. A young boy asked if dogs go
to heaven because his dog just died and he loved that dog so
much. He was anxious to know if his favorite dog is in
heaven to greet him after he dies. Heaven cannot be the happy place
it is purported to be if his faithful is not there to
greet him, he believes.
Father Ryan answered that dogs have no souls and because
of that they cannot be in heaven. I can only imagine how devastated
the young man must have been to receive that discouraging news.
Father Ryan is in a bind, of course. Catholic dogma teaches that
animals don’t have a soul so how can animals be in heaven?
If he replies that the faithful dog is in heaven waiting for
his master then he must confront the difficult theological
questions of how an animal got there.
Heaven must be a dreary place if there are no animals,
flowers, pineapples and sinful girls in it, don’t you think? Filipino
aficionados of cockfighting will just have to find something
else to while away their infinite time in that bleakness.
As for me, I wouldn’t want to go to heaven
and find it populated by girls in ankle length skirts grasping
rosaries. If heaven looks like being dropped into the middle
of a convent I wanna go somewhere else! I wanna go wherever Paris
Hilton, the Playboy Playmates and Katrina Halili are going!
However, there is still hope for the unfortunate heaven-bound.
Early last year, the Roman Catholic Church issued another
opinion regarding that wonderful centuries-old invention of theirs called
“Limbo of the Infants.” Limbo of the Infants is that special
place in the underworld where unbaptized infants go to spend
eternity. According to church dogma, baptism is a pre-requisite
for entry into the exalted halls of heaven and failure to
be baptized is an automatic one-way ticket to Hades. But where
could they banish sinless infants unfortunate enough to
be born and to die in a place far away from a priest and
his magic water?
Almost two thousand years ago, in a stroke of theological genius,
the RCC decided that unbaptized infants
are unceremoniously dropped into a hitherto unknown place called
limbo. No one has seen that place and no such place is ever mentioned
in the bible but nothwithstanding that, the church insists
it must exist and they can even describe it! All from the comfort
a church pulpit.
Unfortunately for theology, modern sensibilities about justice
and punishment have wreaked havoc on that invention. Two thousand
years ago, punishing infants on account of their parent’s
neglect is a common and normal course of life on earth.
It is accepted as a decree from heaven.
Today, such an unmerciful and rabid decree is incompatible
with modern morality. Once again, the infinite Host of Hosts
has been found to harbor unrefined and barbaric tendencies wholly
incompatible with his reputation as a God for all time.
On April 2007, the Church issued an opinion whereby they essentially
said that there is still hope for salvation of unbaptized infants
through means that they do not know about and which they
are unsure about but which they have faith will be duly
revealed in time. Whatever that unrevealed instruments of hope are,
I am sure it will involve huge sums of money to be outlayed by grieving
parents and relatives.
Maybe someday, an expensive but sureproof way of transporting animals,
plants, girlie bars, discos, smut magazines and San Miguel
beer will be found by the geniuses of the church. One can only hope.
Hallelujah!
I’ve always wondered what the church’s position was when it came to souls of beings that aren’t human.
Dear friend,
I don’t know how old you are nor I know much about you.
But because of your thoughts I felt myself close to you.
So I call you friend if you accept as well.
Today I was trying to search for some ads slogans for my company. I actually started searching by the key words “art by automation” to be sure that nobody used it before for any commercial purpose. Then I came across your site. I searched on the page and found what you wrote. It was shortly “death of art by automation”. What I meant is the opposite. I wanted to mean “art by automation”. Anyway this is not the issue now.
I read some of your writings today. They were quite good writings. I paused my work and started reading. I felt really good about you since I had very similar feelings like you expressed in your writings. Though about one thing I do not share the same thoughts. It is about afterlife. I could write you here for hours to prove that there is an afterlife. Yet, I don’t really bother you if you don’t want speak about it. So I decided to ask you first. If you would like we may discuss this topic friendly. I just want to share what I believe. I want to share with you the facts that clears up all the doubts in my mind about the existence of afterlife and surely a God. I believe it so surely as I believe the existence of some form of my own existence.
If you would like to have a chat or a conversation please send me an email. I will write back to you as soon as I can.
If you would like to know about me before writing I add some info below.
I am living in Istanbul Turkey and I am Turkish. I am founder of a technology services company and my brother and my father are my partners. I married a year ago. My wife is Belarussian. I am Muslim from birth but probably not like any kind of stereotype Muslim you may think in your mind. I am religious but also humanist. I am religious but also humane. I am not very well educated or knowledgeable in my faith. Though I see that the more I learn it, the better I am as a person. Better in family, better among relatives, better among friends, better in humanity, better in helping others, better in producing for me and for my country, better in behavior in social life, better in
treating animals, better in saving our environment. Shortly better in conforming any code of conduct about any matter.
Sorry for my English. It is not enough yet to express my thoughts well.
Thank you for your time for reading.
Best Wishes.
Kutlu.
kutluf@gmail.com